newsonaut

Turning inner space into outer space

Friday, November 20, 2026

Newspaper design elements that often didn’t make the transition to the web

Back when I was part of a university web team, I asked a colleague about developing a style for labels. He was confused because we already had a style for the HTML label element used in form controls such as checkboxes.

As an old newspaper man, I was thinking about one- or two-word headings used to set off a section, usually a list. For example, “Contact” might be a label for a list of email addresses. Or “By the numbers” might be a label for a list statistics related to the main article.

We eventually did get a label style — an h4 element with an underline — but wound up calling it something else. (Sorry, I can’t remember what.)

There are a few other design elements from newspapers that also didn’t make the transition, although we could definitely learn from them. I have some ideas about why they aren’t used, but I’ll get to that later.

Kickers

These are short headings over the main headline that help amplify or clarify it. For example, the headline might be: U.S., China and Russia agree to tripartite meeting of leaders. The kicker might be: APEC FORUM. Something like this:

APEC FORUM

U.S., China and Russia agree to tripartite meeting of leaders

The main news is that the leaders of these three countries are meeting. The kicker clarifies where it is taking place.

Subheadings

I do see these occasionally. They are smaller headings under the main headline that give more detail, usually as a way of helping readers understand the importance of the main headline. So something like this:

U.S., China and Russia agree to tripartite meeting of leaders

Summit compared to Yalta conference after Second World War

Styled ledes

The first paragraph of the article would sometimes be styled to make it stand out. For example, the type size and leading might be increased, it might be spread over two columns instead of one, and it might have drop cap as well.

The idea was to make the first paragraph enticingly easy to read. The hope was that if readers made it through the first paragraph, they would carry on to the others. Something like this where I bumped up font-size and line-space to 120 per cent:

U.S. President Donald Trump floated the prospect of reaching a trade deal with Canada soon but said more work needs to be done to get there.

Cutlines

Photos do have captions, but they aren’t quite the same as cutlines. A cutline didn’t just say what was in the picture, it would tell a little story. Someone is doing something, and here’s why. The first few words might be bold face and capitalized, drawing readers’ attention so they might read the rest of it.

Photo credits

Credits often don’t exist or, if they do, they’re tacked on as part of the caption. Newspapers would give the credit right under the picture, separate from the cutline, so it was easy to see. Here’s an example:

— Susie Smith photo

CANADA GEESE attack a dog Tuesday afternoon at Lakeside Park. After a brief scuffle, the dog escaped unscathed. Wildlife expert John Jones says this type of behaviour is not unusual for Canada geese if their chicks are nearby.

Why don’t we see this on the web today?

First, because it is difficult two create web versions of these elements — or at least it was when news outlets first started making the transition. Big improvements in styling have made it much easier, but many of those newspaper conventions have been forgotten.

Second, many articles on the web have goals that are diametrically opposed to those of newspapers. All too often, the goal is to make you slog through a bunch of SEO bumpf before you get to anything like a useful information. The goal of newspapers was to get the facts to you as quickly and plainly as possible.

Third, there isn’t as much space. Most people use a phone or a laptop, both of which have a smaller viewing area than even the smallest newspaper. Other than, say, an “opinion” tag, there just isn’t enough room to fit in all the extras you get with a paper.

I’m not mooning for the good old days of newspapers. I’m all in on digital. But it would be nice to see web designers finding ways to make articles more interesting, and they might want to pull out some newspapers for inspiration.


Search